comparative religions, interfaith, Jewish Israelis, Jewish-Christian relations, Palestinian Christians
There stands a significant barrier between Israeli Jews and Israeli Palestinian Christians learning about each other’s traditions. Each side sees itself as a minority, indeed a double minority. Today I spoke with Ms. Hana Bendcowsky, the Program Director for the Jerusalem Center for Jewish-Christian Relations. Ms. Bendcowsky noted that Israeli Jews see themselves both as Jews in a majority Christian Western world and as Israelis in an Arab region. Israeli Palestinian Christians see themselves as Palestinians in the Jewish Israeli state and as Christians among the majority Muslim Palestinians. For each, this double minority status can give them permission not to listen to the other.
As I have heard before, many Israeli Jews find it difficult not to associate any information about Christianity with the long history of European Christian anti-Semitism. Along with this association comes a hostility to and fear of missionary activity. So “let your children learn about your Christian neighbors” is heard as “open your children up to missionizing activities by the powerful and anti-Semitic Christian world.”
Many Israeli Palestinian Christians will connect information about Judaism with justifications for the Israeli occupation of the West Bank, especially with the more extremist settlers, and with anti-Arab prejudice in Israel. They will also fear breaking ranks with their fellow Israeli Palestinians who are Muslim. Thus “allow your children to learn about your Jewish neighbors” is heard as “open your children up to be co-opted by the oppressor and accused of collaboration.”
In addition to fear, righteous anger is another reaction Ms. Bendcowsky has encountered. “You want me to feel empathy for them? I’m the oppressed one. My job is to protect myself and my community. It is not incumbent upon the victim, or even right, for him to empathize with the persecutor.” Again, this feeling can come either from Israeli Jews or from Israeli Palestinian Christians (and, I suspect, from Israeli Palestinian Muslims.)
What to do? For Ms. Bendcowsky, the work moves through personal connections. She needs to get to know Jewish Israeli teachers, principals, tour guides, and army educators individually. They come to understand that she is an Israeli Jew with no agenda to convert them or their charges. She also needs to get to know Israeli Palestinian Christian principals, teachers, and community leaders. They come to realize that she is not seeking to expand Israeli dominance further into their lives or to divide them from their fellow Palestinians.
Excitingly, JCJCR has been able to work with groups that would not otherwise have learned about “the other.” They have set up partnerships between Jewish and Catholic schools were not at the beginning oriented toward diversity. In these schools some teachers and principals, she reports, have become enthusiastic supporters of learning about each other’s communities. In some of their work in teachers’ colleges Ms. Bendcowsky has seen teachers in training go from complete ignorance about other belief systems to excited fascination with the parallels and divergences between their tradition and those of others.
Very interesting, thanks for posting this.